Version française →

Why ChatGPT Recommends Another Caterer Instead of You

Your regular clients rebook you every year for their corporate events, and word of mouth works well within your existing circle. But new weddings, new family receptions, or new corporate clients you'd never met before are getting harder to come by. If you feel like you're disappearing for people who don't already know you, the reason might not be your food.

A wedding gets planned months in advance. So does a corporate event. And increasingly, the first step of that search no longer starts with a Google query followed by ten browser tabs of comparison. It starts with a question asked directly to an AI: "which caterer would you recommend for an 80-person wedding near [city]" or "find me a reliable caterer for a company retreat." In a single answer, the AI suggests two or three names. If yours isn't one of them, that couple or that company will likely never know you existed.

What ChatGPT looks at before recommending a caterer

When asked to recommend a caterer, a generative AI tries to piece together, from what it finds online, a useful and verifiable answer: what types of events the caterer handles (weddings, corporate, cocktail parties, private buffets), what geographic area they cover, their price range or packages, and what reviews say. The more clearly this information is written somewhere — on your website, in directories, in articles that mention you — the more precisely the AI can build an answer about you.

By contrast, a website limited to an appetizing photo gallery and a contact form, with no text explaining the actual offering, gives an AI nothing to describe you with. Your dishes speak to a human looking at a picture. They say nothing to a language model looking for text to piece together.

The real cause behind the drop in new clients

This is where the shift happens: your regular clients already know you, they call you back directly, without searching. It's the unknown prospects — the ones who've never heard of you — who increasingly go through an AI before discovering you. And if that discovery step fails, there's often no second chance: unlike a Google search where your site might still show up on page 2 or 3, an AI answer often only offers two or three names, with no "next page."

This is exactly the territory of GEO, or Generative Engine Optimization: making your business readable and verifiable to an AI, the same way traditional search optimization made your site visible on Google. The difference is that AI doesn't just match keywords — it needs to understand your offering the way a human would, by carefully reading your site, your reviews, and what's said about you elsewhere.

What this actually changes for your business

A caterer who doesn't show up in these answers isn't just losing "a bit of visibility" — they're losing high-value quotes, for events that take months to plan and get decided quickly once the shortlist is set. If the AI consistently suggests the same two or three competitors for weddings or corporate events in your area, they're the ones receiving quote requests from clients you've never met, while your calendar only fills up through word of mouth from existing clients.

What you can check yourself in 5 minutes

1. Open ChatGPT and ask: "which caterer would you recommend for a wedding in [your city]?" Note whether you appear, at what position, and who gets cited instead.
2. Ask the same question for a corporate event: the caterers cited can differ depending on the type of event.
3. Repeat with Perplexity and Gemini to see if the answer changes across AIs.
4. Reread your own website the way an AI would: can it clearly tell what types of events you cater, what area you serve, and what sets you apart — or does it have to guess from the photos?

If the answers skip you or keep citing the same competitors, that's not a matter of culinary talent — it's a lack of information an AI can actually use, and it can be fixed.