My SEO Agency Never Mentions ChatGPT or AI — Should I Be Worried?

🇫🇷 Version française

You've been paying an SEO agency for months, the monthly reports show flawless Google rankings, and yet new inquiries still aren't picking up. A client even told you, "I asked ChatGPT and it recommended someone else." Your agency has never once said that word in a meeting.

It's a doubt that creeps in gradually, not an alarm bell. Your SEO agency's monthly report checks every box: keywords on page one, steady traffic, a few new backlinks. On paper, everything looks fine. But in practice, the number of new prospects reaching out has stalled, maybe even slipped a little, and you can't quite connect the two. You've reread the last few reports: not once do the words ChatGPT, Perplexity, or "artificial intelligence" appear.

Flawless reports, but still fewer new inquiries: why the gap?

This gap is more common than you'd think, and it doesn't necessarily mean your SEO agency is doing bad work in the classic sense. They're likely still optimizing exactly what they were hired to optimize: your Google ranking. The problem is that a growing share of your prospects no longer go through that results list at all. They open ChatGPT or Perplexity directly, ask their question — "which company should I choose for [your service]" — and get a ready-made answer, with one or two names. Nobody in your current setup is tracking that channel.

Why your agency never brings it up

Most SEO agencies measure what they've known how to measure for fifteen years: keyword rankings, organic traffic volume, number of inbound links. These are solid indicators for Google, but they say nothing about your citation in an AI-generated answer — that's a different mechanism, relying on neither the same signals nor the same tracking tools. Many agencies simply haven't built this dimension into their method yet, not out of negligence, but because it's not what they were historically asked to track. This is exactly the territory of GEO (Generative Engine Optimization): making your business citable by generative AIs, a discipline distinct from classic Google search optimization, with its own levers.

What this silence actually changes for you

The risk isn't that your classic SEO is useless — it still matters for the share of traffic that still goes through a traditional Google search. The risk is that you're funding one floor of the building while an increasingly busy channel is left completely unaddressed, without you or your provider realizing it. You keep paying for real, but partial, work, believing it covers the whole picture. The gap only shows up in your numbers months later, once the cumulative effect of missed opportunities becomes hard to ignore.

What you can check yourself in 5 minutes

1. Reread your last three SEO reports: look for the words ChatGPT, Perplexity, generative AI, or "AI Overviews." If none appear, that's the first sign.
2. Open ChatGPT or Perplexity and ask the question a prospect would ask about your business. See whether your company is cited, and which one comes up instead.
3. Ask your agency directly at the next check-in: "are you tracking our citation in AI answers, and what are you actually doing about it?" The answer — precise or vague — will tell you a lot.
4. Compare with a competitor you know is active online: if they're cited by the AI and you're not, the question stops being theoretical.